Arsenal manager Mikel Arteta launched a scathing post-match attack after Nick Pope escaped with a yellow card for hauling down Viktor Gyökeres in the 74th minute of the Gunners’ 1-0 win over Newcastle United on April 25, 2026. The incident sparked intense debate over the application of the DOGSO (denial of an obvious goal-scoring opportunity) law, though VAR deemed the on-field decision correct.
Incident and VAR Decision
The moment unfolded when a through ball sent Gyökeres clear behind the Newcastle defence. Pope rushed out of his area, slipped, then grabbed the Arsenal striker as both chased the loose ball. Referee Sam Barrott issued a yellow card, judging that an obvious goal-scoring opportunity had not been denied.
VAR official Jarred Gillett reviewed the incident and confirmed Barrott’s call. The key factor was the presence of a covering Newcastle defender who had a realistic chance of intercepting the ball. According to Law 12, all criteria — including distance to goal, direction of play, likelihood of controlling the ball, and number of defenders — must align for a red card. VAR concluded they did not.
Arteta’s Reaction
Arteta was furious, calling the decision a clear red card. “I have to say as well in my opinion, it is a clear red card,” he said. “I have watched it ten times. If you have ever played football, it is a red card.” His frustration was compounded by a similar incident a week earlier against Manchester City, when Kai Havertz was fouled by Abdukodir Khusanov without sanction — a decision Arteta believes should have resulted in a red card and potentially changed the outcome of their 2-1 defeat.
Refereeing Expert Analysis
Former elite referee Andy Davies backed the officials, stating the decision was correct under current protocols. While Pope’s challenge was rash, the proximity of a defender and uncertainty over whether Gyökeres would control the ball meant the DOGSO threshold was not met. “This was a relatively straightforward decision,” Davies said, adding that Arteta’s reaction was surprising given the facts on the pitch.
Despite Arsenal moving back to the top of the Premier League, the Gunners’ title campaign is growing increasingly tense — and Arteta believes officiating inconsistencies are mounting against them.